Experts called for the repeal of tougher laws for sex workers

A group of more than 80 experts has called for the repeal of stricter rules for sex workers in Ireland.

The proposal was made by academic experts, lawyers, sociologists, criminologists, economists, and scientists from the University of Limerick, UCC, UCD, Trinity College, Maynooth University, NUI Galway, Griffith College, Technological University, Dublin.

Solicitor Maura Butler was hired as an independent expert last July to analyze the 2017 law criminalizing giving money for sex.

Their demand is that the provision that it is a crime to enjoy sex for money has many shortcomings and therefore the provision should be repealed. They also say the current law makes sex work more dangerous.

On March 27, 2017, Ireland adopted the ‘Nordic model’ and criminalized sex purchase. The government says it is aimed at protecting vulnerable people from exploitation and prostitution.

However, the sex workers’ organisations have raised huge protests against the law. They also say the laws make sex workers more vulnerable.

It was just two years after the law had been enforced that a male defendant was tried. Several women were arrested and deported for the offenses of keeping a brothel.

The Ugly Mugs, a security service for sex workers, estimates that sex workers deal with 6,000 to 7,000 people a year.

Crimes related to prostitution have increased significantly since the law came into force. In 2016, 34 cases were registered and in 2019, the number rose to 112.

The panel of experts recommended that legislation be enacted that would not further harass sex workers. They also call for the repeal of laws and regulations that prohibit the sale, purchase, and organized sex.

They argue that blaming the person seeking sex is a false signal of sexual violence and exploitation. Also that the law does not make the lives of sex workers better, but rather creates a dangerous situation.

An approach that prioritizes the safety of sex workers is needed. They point out that the current laws adversely affect sex workers and endanger their health and safety.